Bookmark and Share

Article Image

Jeff Buckley vs The X Factor

'there is an uprising among the hoards of Buckley fans in cyberspace...'


Perusing the Internet today, I had my eye taken by the rather shocking news that the winner of this years X Factor will be releasing ‘Hallelujah’ in their attempt to reach the hallowed Christmas Number One.  Two emotions prevailed upon me discovering this:



1: Shock, that The X Factor are covering an ostensibly alternative tune for such an important release.  Also, the fact they would release a song creating a somewhat William Blake-esque link between religion and sexual pleasure seemed to be a bit of an almighty risk for them when you consider the target audience.



2: Disappointment that they, the very embodiment of everything that there is to despise about the music industry, are covering a tune long treasured by myself and countless others. Admittedly this affection is almost singularly for the Jeff Buckley version and not the Leonard Cohen original. But this is one of the rare cases where the cover is better than the original, where the coverer makes the song their own, as if they had penned it in the first place.  The Buckley legend has been grotesquely flogged since his untimely death over a decade ago, with a wave of ill-informed live releases and dodgy studio recordings, but if you forget these and ask most fans for the defining song of Buckley, the one shining beacon of his talent and voice, it would probably be ‘Hallelujah.’



Upon reflection, my sense of shock dispersed as fast as it came.  Of COURSE they are releasing this song! What a chorus; instantly memorable, impossible to forget and with a religious overtone around this most holy time of year.  There’s a real Holy Trinity for you!
       



And who gives a fuck what the song is actually about? Who cares that it contains the lines: But remember when I moved in you/ And the holy dove was moving too/ And every breath we drew was Hallelujah.  Sure, that’s not family friendly, but they can just edit that out. And no-one really listens to that bit do they?! It’s all about the ‘Hallelujah.’ That’s the money shot.

        

So it is somewhat heartening that there is an uprising among the hoards of Buckley fans in cyberspace, where social networking types are starting a campaign to get the Buckley version to the top ahead of the Cowell Cock-Up.  One group on Facebook- Jeff Buckley for Xmas no 1- is thriving with, as I write, 7,931 members (most of which have only joined since Tuesday, the group founder Lucy tells me), so there is clearly people out there who believe in the cause. Unfortunately, this is not enough as breaking Cowell’s grip on the Christmas Number One slot is a massive task, especially when you consider previous X Factor form(571,253 first week sales for Leona
Lewis's ‘A Moment Like This' anyone?)   

      

There appears to be no plans to make ‘Hallelujah’ a physical release therefore

(somewhat ironically) the only way for people to vote with their feet is to download a copy of the song.  Now I’m not one for being over-precious about music I like (hello Beatles fans) but I would love this to be one battle the ordinary folk do win because, beyond the fact that it is a great song and surely better than the syrupy tripe JLS et al will no doubt churn out, aren’t we all a bit bored with The X Factor? Wouldn’t it be nice to see a real, actual instrument playing musician at number one this Christmas? And wouldn’t it be a rather fitting tribute to Buckley’s musical legacy if he, the most sensitive of songsmith’s, could defeat the immovable tyrant?



So come on music fans; click on the link, splash the cash (after the 15th of December mind) and wipe the grin off Cowell’s face, at least for five minutes.


Comments

Please login to add a comment

  • robbie

    18-Dec-2008

    robbie

    I never really got into jeff buckley i have a burnt copy of grace but found it a bit samey.
    thought that x factor one was actually ok.

  • rupert

    18-Dec-2008

    rupert

    Firstly jeffs version is better, thats obvious, no debate there. secondly we as music fans hate x factor, again no debate.
    but.... i dont think Hallelujah is actually his defining moment i think last goodbye or lover you should of come over are far better songs, lightyears better.
    I feel if x factor wanna cover a buckley tune let it be the most obvious, the most commercial rather than spoil any of the others.

  • Chris

    14-Dec-2008

    Chris

    I am not supporting X-Factor. It is what it is. After hearing a preview of the winner's song on the final show I am appalled at the way Hallelujah was treated - over-the-top clichéd and predictable. I will be interested to hear the arrangement of the 'single' to see if it is cut down from original.

    David: I did not say that you were fuelling negativity. I am annoyed that Hallelujah is at the centre of all this.

  • MarkB

    13-Dec-2008

    MarkB

    Who owns the rights? That be Leonard Cohen of course. He played the o2 at 70 odd years of age this year only because he couldn't turn down the money they offered. Looks like this has been a good year all round for Mr Cohen

  • Stuart

    13-Dec-2008

    Stuart

    I think the real point here is who actually owns the rights to the song and would let that fuckwit Cowell prostitute it so that teenagers would buy it en masse.

Page: 1 2 3

Gobshout News

Sign in

Email

Password

Single Reviews